What Is a Super Lawyer? The Rating Explained (2026)
What is a Super Lawyer? How the selection process works, whether the rating is worth it, what it costs, and how to use it in your law firm's marketing.
What is a Super Lawyer? If you've shopped for an attorney — or been named to the list yourself — you've seen the badge, but the rating is widely misunderstood. Some attorneys treat it as a meaningless pay-to-play sticker; others wear it like a Nobel Prize. The truth sits in between, and knowing how the selection actually works helps you decide whether it's worth pursuing and how to use it in your marketing.
This guide explains exactly what the Super Lawyers rating is, how attorneys get selected, what it costs, whether it's legitimate, and how to leverage it without overstepping the ethics rules.
What Super Lawyers actually is
Super Lawyers is a rating service (owned by Thomson Reuters) that names outstanding attorneys across more than 70 practice areas. Each year it publishes state-by-state lists recognizing lawyers who have "attained a high degree of peer recognition and professional achievement."
The key number: no more than 5% of the attorneys in a state are selected to the Super Lawyers list in any given year. That scarcity is a big part of why the recognition carries weight.
There's also a companion list, Rising Stars, for younger or newer attorneys — limited to no more than 2.5% of lawyers in a state, who are either 40 or under or have been practicing for 10 years or less.
How the selection process works
This is where Super Lawyers differs from a simple directory. Selection runs through a multi-step, patented process each year:
- Nominations. Attorneys are nominated by their peers — lawyers can nominate others (but generally not themselves), and the research team also identifies candidates.
- Independent research. Thomson Reuters evaluates candidates against a set of indicators: verdicts and settlements, experience, honors and awards, bar activity, pro bono work, scholarly writing, and more.
- Peer evaluation ("blue ribbon" panels). Top-scoring candidates in each practice area are reviewed by peers in the same field.
- Final selection. Candidates are grouped by firm size and practice area, and the highest-point earners make the list — capped at that 5% (or 2.5% for Rising Stars).
Crucially, you cannot buy your way onto the list. Paying Super Lawyers gets you advertising and profile placement — not selection. That distinction is what separates it from pure pay-to-play directories.
Is Super Lawyers legitimate — and worth it?
For most attorneys, yes, with a clear-eyed view of what it is:
The case for it:
- The 5% cap and peer-review process give it genuine selectivity and credibility.
- The badge is a recognizable, third-party trust signal that reassures prospective clients.
- Profiles often rank well in search for attorney-name queries, adding another credible result about you.
- It carries weight with referral sources and other attorneys.
The honest caveats:
- Selection is free, but displaying the badge, plaques, and enhanced profiles cost money — that's the business model.
- It's recognition, not a guarantee of results. A great lawyer can be left off; a listed lawyer isn't automatically the right fit.
- Clients weigh it alongside reviews, experience, and their own impression — it's one input, not the whole decision.
Bottom line: if you're selected, it's a worthwhile credential to accept and display. Just don't mistake the badge itself for a marketing strategy.
What it costs
Being selected costs nothing. What costs money is everything after: display plaques, a "digital badge" license, enhanced online profiles, and print/online advertising in the Super Lawyers magazines and directory. Pricing varies, and none of it affects whether you were chosen — only how prominently you're promoted.
How to leverage it in your marketing
If you've earned the recognition, put it to work — tastefully and within the rules:
- Display the badge on your website, ideally near your calls to action and in your attorney bios where it reinforces credibility at the decision moment.
- Mention it in context — "Selected to Super Lawyers [year]" with the year, rather than implying it's permanent or a guarantee.
- Add it to your profiles across the directories and review sites where clients research you.
- Keep it in proportion. It's one of several trust signals; pair it with reviews, results, and a professional website rather than leaning on it alone.
Mind the advertising rules
Attorney advertising is regulated, and ratings claims are a common area of scrutiny. Many states have rules about how you can present awards and comparative claims — some require you to name the issuing organization, the year, or add disclaimers. Before you splash the badge everywhere, review your jurisdiction's requirements; our overview of lawyer advertising rules is a good starting point.
Also worth knowing: Super Lawyers is one of several attorney ratings. Martindale-Hubbell's "AV Preeminent" peer rating and "Best Lawyers" are other recognized credentials, each with its own methodology. Together they form a credibility stack — but each should be presented accurately.
The bottom line
So, what is a Super Lawyer? It's a selective, peer-reviewed recognition given to no more than 5% of a state's attorneys each year — legitimate, credible, and worth displaying if you earn it, as long as you treat it as one trust signal among many and present it within the rules.
Want to turn credentials like this into a website that actually converts the clients who find you? Get in touch and let's make every trust signal you've earned work as hard as it should.